A bridge of repair for Native and Black America

Chip Cowell

The return of looted Native American ancestors and belongings can illuminate the call for African-American reparations

The recent weeks of protest across the United States against anti-Black racism and police violence have revived conversations about reparations for Black Americans whose ancestors suffered from the terrors of slavery and its aftermath. 

Fresh arguments have arrived that international law demands reparations, that racial justice requires it, and that they are needed to address the nation’s racial wealth disparities. 

The California Assembly is poised to establish a commission to study how the state could pursue reparations, and in the U.S. Congress, H.R. 40, which would establish a commission at a national level is gaining traction. 

Long considered, as Ta-Nehisi Coates wrote in his celebrated article, “The Case for Reparations,” “a harebrained scheme authored by wild-eyed lefties and intellectually unserious black nationalists,” the possibility of reparations suddenly seems very real.

As Americans tussle with the idea of financial and institutional reparations, insight can be gained from other movements that have sought to redress historic injustices. One such injustice was the removal of more than 200,000 skeletons, millions of grave goods, and thousands of sacred objects—stolen from Native Americans. 

For more than 12 years as a curator at the Denver Museum of Nature & Science, I worked to implement a federal law called the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA), which facilitates the return of ancestors and objects.

The histories of slavery and the looting of Native America are different quilts of shame and yet were woven from the same threads. Repatriation offers a poignant comparison for a reparations law that would compel institutions to confront the question of plunder and the aspiration of reconciliation.

Graverobbing Native America’s dead began with fantasies of white supremacy. In 1784, Thomas Jefferson excavated a large burial mound in Virginia, to investigate whether Native Americans were truly advanced and “civilized” enough to master such feats of engineering. 

It was widely presumed that the massive structures could only have been made by a “Lost Race,” often thought to be misplaced Israelites, Phoenicians, Greeks, or others of Old World antiquity. 

Such presumptions of Native American inferiority were spurred on in 1839 with Samuel George Morton’s famed book, Crania Americana, which offered highly detailed illustrations of 78 skulls to argue that humans could be categorized into five distinct races, with of course the “white man” on top.

To reaffirm such narratives, and because Native Americans were presumed to be fast fading and incapable of serving as stewards of their own heritage, in the decades that followed unknown thousands of Native American graves were plundered. 

Additionally, taken from living cultures were sacred and communally-owned objects, which often interrupted religious and traditional practices. These acts served to divorce Native Americans from their own heritage and robbed many of their dignity and humanity.

Slavery was a horrific form of violence, most immediately in its physical harm. People from Africa were forced to suffer endless toil and corporeal abuse, and have their families broken apart through the sale of spouses and children. Even with the end of slavery, the horrors did not end. 

Liberty continued to be stolen, as well as what little many of the descendants of slavery possessed. Lynchings, disenfranchisement, embezzlement of land through debt peonage. Segregation, educational and work opportunities denied, housing discrimination through redlining and a prejudiced banking system, police violence, and more.

As Ta-Nehisi Coates argued, Black Americans have suffered a “quiet plunder” of their lives and property. So too American museums plundered Native Americans and their cultures. 

It seems no small coincidence that when looking at the history of English America, the  first enslaved persons from Africa arrived not far from Jamestown in 1619 while the first Native American grave was plundered not far from Plymouth Rock in 1620.

The slavery of people from Africa and the looting of Native American ancestors and belongings are not the same. Yet, the repatriation and reparation movements are most basically about intergenerational plunder: the theft of lives, property, and cultures. Both movements are a response to a history of white supremacy, and so their moral demands are shared.

After decades of protests, NAGPRA finally became law in 1990. The process of complying with the law has often proven to be uneven, difficult, and flawed. And yet, NAGPRA has now facilitated the return of some 1.7 million grave goods, 57,000 skeletons, and 15,000 sacred and communally owned objects to tribes and lineal descendants. This process has led to new collaborations and mutually beneficial museum practices. And, for many, it has led to healing.

In his now famed essay on reparations, Coates observes that the United States can never truly repay African-Americans for what was—and still is—being taken from them. 

The same seems true for Native Americans. Repatriation does not wind back the clock; we cannot unloot the dead. However, Coates adds, “What I’m talking about is more than recompense for past injustices—more than a handout, a payoff, hush money, or a reluctant bribe. What I’m talking about is a national reckoning that would lead to spiritual renewal.”

This vision is already unfolding in parts of Native America, thanks in some measure to the return of stolen ancestors and property. The law will always be imperfect—repatriation and reparations can never fully repair what was broken in the past. But these attempts most basically are not about looking backward. They are about settling our accounts so that we can write a different future.

Chip Cowell is the editor-in-chief of Sapiens.org, an anthropologist and the author and editor of 12 books that address the intersection of history and politics. Among his most recent books is Plundered Skulls and Stolen Spirits: Inside the Fight to Reclaim Native America’s Culture (University of Chicago Press). Cowell has published op-eds and essays in the New York Times, The Atlantic, The Guardian, and Indian Country Today.

Comments (3)
No. 1-3
JMY54
JMY54

Recapitulation of Historic Trauma?

What’s good about the Warren debacle is that, for many, it raises Native issues to national and global consciousness. As the Americas and their riches are desired by many world nations, it’s unsurprising that most media outlets refuse to talk about the ongoing de-indigenization and predation of our Native homelands. As highlighted by the Dakota Access pipeline fight with the Standing Rock Sioux, the Elliot Abrams hearing spotlighting political and military manipulation of Latin governments, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s objection to the Trump border wall based on our Native indigeneity, or Venezuela’s 20 year refusal to bow to US pressures, our resources, our bodies and our politics are under constant assault by settler-colonial policy and action.

In 1600, Bolivia’s Potosi mountain provided all the silver and over 90% of the wealth for a failing Europe. The Potosi mine claimed 16,000 Native American lives, and its remnants claim them still. Similarly, the gold rush in South Dakota’s Black Hills and California’s mountains claimed the lives of thousands of American Indians. With genomic and Omics technology being analogous in power to the splitting of the atom, genomic data have the potential to generate great wealth. Indeed, one only has to look at the money being invested by public and private funders in Omics technologies to see how it might recapitulate theft from the Indigenous. However, just like those gold and silver mines and hundreds of other Amerindigenous products (corn, rubber, quinine, taxol and chocolate), none of us will benefit from a product that originated with our own bodies. http://kpppfm.com/articles/the-warren-debacle-exacerbates-a-527-year-old-problem/

ka la la
ka la la

I suggest this book: Brethren by Nature: New England Indians, Colonists, and the Origins of American Slavery, which received the 2016 James Rawley prize for best book on the history of race relations in America: http://www.cornellpress.cornell.edu/book/?GCOI=80140100460180.
So I think the common word for this in Indian Country is colonization, as in colonizing minds or hiding the truth. I wrote a paper recently on Empire and how they don't write (hi)story. The key to the past: We are not supposed to know.
Reparations are long overdue. Looting is part of the system of colonization.

mamalabamba
mamalabamba

A fascinated article on the plundering of ancestors's remains in Indian locations reinforces the systemic racism which has kept Native Americans from participating fully in US "progress"and development. The article made me wonder whether research has ever tackled the plundering of Native American Art. In lower North Denver, CO. a blasphemous White Wall was erected in 2009 to hide a gorgeous 30-year old Indigenous folk art mural of Our Lady of Guadalupe in the church that bears her name because the pastor felt it was a "distraction." Since then Faithful United parishioners have been fighting to have this infamous WHITE WALL TORN DOWN to no avail. The hidden mural has been sitting behind that wall for over 10 years being used as a trash closet. The artist who created the mural is still alive and has offered to RESTORE the mural to its original brilliance without any response from the church. All other evidence of ethnic art has also been erased from this church. One can't help but surmise that this WHITE WALL is another symbol of sytemic neo-colonial racism raised to hide an Indigenous folk art mural that does not fit into the standard White European model of sanitized iconography. Just wondering whether this abuse warrants a follow up by your staff.


Opinion

FEATURED
COMMUNITY