Sixties Scoop: Personal Stories of Adoption in Canada

Michelle Siu/Canadian Press / Sixties Scoop survivors and supporters gather for a demonstration at a Toronto courthouse on Tuesday, August 23, 2016.

Indian Country Today

The Sixties Scoop legacy troubles both adoptees and their parents.

Editor’s note: As the Sixties Scoop lawsuit made its way through the legal system in Canada, adoptees and their parents had conflicting feelings about the issue, as these two companion pieces to “Adoptees Seeking Redress: Canada Confronts the Sixties Scoop” illustrate.

Children: Taught to Hide Her Heritage

Little effort was put into preserving adoptees’ Aboriginal culture once they were removed from reserves. Some were not even aware of their Aboriginal status. Others were told to keep it quiet.

Nakuset, who goes by just one name, was adopted at age three by a Jewish family and raised in the tony Westmount area of Montreal. Her adoptive mother told her she was picked—because she was “cute”—from a catalogue of Native children circulated by Montreal’s Jewish Family Services. She was told to tell people she was adopted from Israel. She went to Hebrew school, Jewish summer camp and was encouraged to date Jewish boys, “but I just never fit in,” says Nakuset, whose birth name, Margaret, was changed to Miriam when she was adopted and changed again at age 22 when a Mi’kmaq elder renamed her Nakuset.

Like many Aboriginal adoptees, Nakuset left home as soon as she could, when she was 18. She floundered for a few years and then gained back her Native status, which paid for a university degree. The only positive thing about her adoption was the relationship she had with her Jewish grandmother, who lived down the street and doted on her. “My bubbe was the most incredibly loving woman. She was my salvation, and she saw greatness in me.”

Today, Nakuset, 44, is the executive director of the Native Women’s Shelter of Montreal, co-president of the Montreal Urban Aboriginal Community Strategy Network and host of the community TV show Indigenous Power. Last year, the Montreal Council of Women named her Woman of the Year. In her speech at the awards event, she thanked her deceased grandmother for believing in her.

As for her adoptive parents, she says in an interview, “I totally disappointed them. There is no relationship.”

Parents: The Best of Intentions

It isn’t difficult to find United Church families who adopted Aboriginal children during the scoop era. When contacted by The Observer, some were reluctant to share their stories. One parent, who adopted two Aboriginal children who have since died—one had fetal alcohol syndrome and the other schizophrenia—said it was too painful to discuss, stating simply in an e-mail, “Beautiful children; unhappy end to our story.”

Margaret Ward and her late husband, Jack, a psychiatrist, who were active at St. Andrew’s United in Sudbury, Ont., adopted two Aboriginal girls ages eight and 12 and made an effort to expose them to their culture by bringing them to powwows and on visits to their home reserve. Ward, 79, a retired college professor who now lives in Arizona, says the adoptions were done “with good intentions” and dislikes the term “Sixties Scoop” since it implies children were taken without good reason. “It denigrates the intentions of the people who were involved.” She says several siblings of her adopted daughters had early deaths. “I wonder what my daughters’ lives would have been like if they stayed.”

Very Rev. Robert Smith, a United Church moderator from 1984 to 1986, and his wife, Ellen, adopted an infant Aboriginal daughter, born to a teenage girl, 50 years ago. Their daughter pursued her Métis roots as an adult, earning a master of education with a focus on Aboriginal art and reconnecting with her birth parents in her 40s. The Smiths aren’t sure what to think of the term “Sixties Scoop,” but Robert says today he recognizes that “white social workers did not understand the family structure of Indian society. They had no concept of the extended family and the fact that for a child to be without their natural mother or father did not mean the child would be raised poorly or deprived, because other members of the extended family could take their place.” Adds Ellen, “Children were taken out of homes with no appreciation of their culture. In most cases, people did it with good motivation, but the philosophy behind it all was that the child’s culture had nothing to offer.” Robert Smith offered the United Church’s first apology to First Nations peoples in 1986.

Raven Sinclair, an associate professor in the faculty of social work at the University of Regina, was adopted at age five by Rev. Robert Bater, a United Church minister and former principal of Queen’s Theological College, and his wife. She and her six siblings had been removed from their mother’s home in Saskatchewan due to neglect. Sinclair, 53, has nothing but good things to say about her late adoptive father, praising him for “doing some serious evaluation about the motive for my adoption” and admitting he had been “misled” about the idea that she had been “rescued” from the reserve.

“He was accountable and ethical and anti-racist. He recognized that our lifestyle, even in a well-intentioned, United Church, white, middle-class family was racist,” she says. “Growing up, I had so many people say to me, ‘You’re not like other Indians. You’re lucky you were adopted away from all that.’”

Her father, she says, came to regret her adoption, even though he loved her. “He knew that despite their good intentions, they couldn’t give me what I needed: my Indigenous heritage, my language, my culture. People can have the best of intentions, but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t wrong.”

This article was originally published in April 2015 in The United Church Observer magazine. Reprinted with permission.

Comments (1)
No. 1-1

Hi Everyone !

My name is Stephen H. I am a full blooded Cree Native American from Canada. Sadly, I am also part of the 60's Scoop.

The “Sixties Scoop” refers to the large-scale removal or “scooping” of Indigenous children from their homes, communities and families of birth through the 1960s, and their subsequent adoption into predominantly non-Indigenous, middle-class families across the United States and Canada. This experience left many adoptees with a lost sense of cultural identity. The physical and emotional separation from their birth families continues to affect adult adoptees and Indigenous communities to this day.

My story started when I was only 18 months old. I was put into adoption days after been taken away from my family. I was adopted out to a German couple who already had 4 kids of their own at the time. So I spent almost 10 years growing up in Regina Saskatchewan confused as a young boy as I was never taught anything about my heritage or my culture. I was raised as a little German boy and for a long time I thought that I was German. I did have a decent childhood for the most part, being raised 'Old School' went a long way to build who I have become today.

At 10 yrs old, we moved from Saskatchewan to Ontario where life for me began to become less desirable to live in. New school, New people lead to me having some real issues arise. So as a result i decided to leave home at age 10. 2 years later, my adopted parents decided that they couldn't handle me anymore and decided to give me back to Children's Aid as a Crown Ward. WOW eh....

Needless to say, After being taken away from your family to begin with, grow up with a new family for 10 years and then given back to the agency who took me in the first place- The answer is YES.. I had a few psychological problems develop. I decided to move to Toronto and live on the streets. I lived on streets for about 9 years before I joined a traveling carnival where I spent 2 years running the Gravitron and Tilt-a-whirl rides. I then met my ex-wife and had 2 wonderful children. Got separated for 10 years and am now engaged to my beautiful girlfriend of 3 years. I am currently disabled due to work injuries but have gained quite a bit of knowledge rebuilding and repairing computers, Web-design, Android app making, And my personal favorite hobby is Making music for all of you to expand your consciousness as well as reconfigure the mind to make better choices and be more aware of everything around you. I practice alot of meditation, Sacred chanting, and being an all around good person as we all start this process of 'Waking-Up'

Thank you for taking the time to read this and stopping by to check me out. I simply ask of you, if you are unable to support me by purchasing a song, album or making a donation, then I simply encourage to you to just pass my name around to your friends and family.

Thank you for your time and support !

Dj Liquidn8v