Skip to main content

Cladoosby Hopes to Initiate Repatriation Discussion With France

NCAI President Brian Cladoosby hopes his meeting French President Francois Hollande on Feb. 11 is enough to open up talks of Native repatriation.

National Congress of American Indians President Brian Cladoosby doesn’t expect he’ll have more than an opportunity to shake the hand of French President Francois Hollande at a White House state dinner February 11.

But he hopes that introduction will open the door to negotiation of an agreement for the repatriation of Native American objects in French museums.

Cladoosby, chairman of the Swinomish Tribe, and his wife Nina were invited by President Barack Obama and Mrs. Obama to the state dinner being held in honor of the French president.

During the French president’s visit to the U.S., Obama and Hollande “will discuss opportunities to further strengthen the U.S.-France security and economic partnership,” Obama said in a statement posted on

“Michelle and I look forward to welcoming President Hollande … on a state visit to the United States,” Obama said.

“The United States and France are close friends and allies, including through NATO, and our countries have worked together to support democracy, liberty, and freedom at home and abroad for more than two centuries.”

The state dinner comes two months after a French judge’s decision to allow an auction house in Paris to sell 24 sacred Native American artifacts, despite the protests of the Hopi Nation, the U.S. Embassy, and indigenous civil rights organization Survival International.

RELATED: Sad But True: Another Hopi Katsinam Auction Planned in Paris

The Annenberg Foundation intervened, submitting a winning bid of $530,000 U.S. for the sole purpose of returning the objects to their rightful owners – 21 items belong to the Hopi Nation, three to the San Carlos Apache.

RELATED: Surprise! Charity Buys 21 Sacred Katsinam for Hopi at Auction in Paris

The Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act gives indigenous nations in the U.S. a way to reclaim funerary objects and ceremonial items from federal agencies and museums in the United States. The law, however, does not apply to items held internationally.

Christopher Marinello, executive director and general counsel of Art Loss Register London, the world’s largest private database of lost and stolen art, antiques and collectables, told ICTMN in April 2013 that the Hopi and Apache objects should have been repatriated under the 1970 UNESCO Convention on the Means of Prohibiting and Preventing the Illicit Import, Export and Transfer of Ownership of Cultural Property. France ratified the convention in 1997.

RELATED: Hopi Katsinam and Nazi Art Theft: An Expert Discusses Principles of Repatriation

Scroll to Continue

Read More

According to the convention, “the [Hopi and Apache] pieces should have been pulled off, parties should have had a discussion to see which pieces could be sold, which were not genuine, what were the moral claims, what was important to the tribe, what is the compensation,” Marinello told ICTMN.

Marinello said there are no international agreements specifically addressing Native American artifacts, and said “it is something that the Americans should be convening and discussing because the laws in the USA protecting those Native artifacts have no weight overseas.”

That’s what Cladoosby hopes to initiate, noting, “We want to ensure our most sacred items are treated the same way” as those covered by other repatriation conventions.

If and when Cladoosby and Hollande meet in the future, the NCAI president will likely have left an impression that will have been hard to forget; Cladoosby said his formal wear will be completed by a Coast Salish cedar hat, cedar vest and bolo tie.

A White House state dinner is held in honor of a foreign head of state and is hosted by the president of the United States in the State Dining Room.

State dinners are dictated by strict protocol. The visiting leader is welcomed by the president and first lady at the North Portico entrance of the White House; a reception follows in the Yellow Oval Room, then dinner in the State Dining Room. Guests enjoy a four- or five-course dinner using settings from earlier presidencies. After dinner, guests are formally entertained by a musical ensemble – a band, orchestra, pianist or singer of national renown – in the East Room.

It’s Cladoosby’s second invitation to the White House; he attended the White House Christmas party three years ago.

“I’m pretty excited to be invited,” he said.

The first visiting indigenous head of state to attend a state dinner at the White House was King David Kalakaua of the Kingdom of Hawaii, hosted by President Ulysses S. Grant in 1874. Indigenous presence has been rare since then. Here’s a few:

Charles Curtis, a citizen of the Kaw Nation, was U.S. vice president when President Herbert Hoover hosted a state dinner for the king and queen of Siam in April 1931.

In October 1994, President Bill Clinton hosted a state dinner for South African President Nelson Mandela, who was of the Xhosa Tribe. (Tulalip Tribes Chairman Stan Jones was a guest at one of Clinton’s inaugural balls).

At the June 2011, state dinner for German Chancellor Angela Merkel, guests enjoyed vegetables from the White House Kitchen Garden that had been harvested by Michelle Obama and Native American children as part of a program to promote healthy eating.

Cladoosby said of Obama’s efforts to strengthen the relationship between the U.S. and tribes: “I’ve been on [the Swinomish] council for 29 years now and I’ve witnessed a lot of presidents. [Tribes] had one meeting with Clinton, none with [George W.] Bush, and five with this president in five years. This invitation is just another indication of the importance he places on the relationship between tribes and the U.S. We will not always agree, but we can talk and work together to find middle ground. That’s what a relationship is.”